The End is Nigh?

‘If the university cannot be transformed’, audaciously declares Richard Hall, then ‘it must be abolished’. Hall, professor of education and technology at De Montfort University, is the author of aptly titled, The Hopeless University. His words alone cannot abolish the university. But they can place it under contention, daring us to temporarily suspend its very idea. They can help us imagine what could otherwise take its place. So, this is surely more than a provocation.

The assertion speaks to many deeply held frustrations. Universities, far from liberating us from our darkest prejudices and unseemly biases, now only act to incubate them and shield a tarnished and failing status quo. ‘Progress,’ for what it means, has actually led to social discord and the stagnation of living standards in the West. Democracy is on the wane or is at least perceived as having entered a highly dysfunctional phase. Leaders of Western European nations are plumbing new depths of unpopularity and are under attack by autocrats and strongmen of reactionary bent and self-serving impulses. Fascism has taken hold and is on the rise in Europe and the US. But universities appear to be unable to assist in turning this tide. They are seemingly incapable of extending democratic and civic practices across highly educated and professionalised domestic populations. Indeed, some are arguing, based on clear evidence, that western universities are promoting suppression of freedom of speech, ignoring racism and sexism within their walls, and turning a blind eye to genocide and human suffering. Universities, it appears, seem to function to enhance stratifications of social prestige through new forms of academic labour, discipline and management. Furthermore, misinformation has proliferated through new forms of communications technology to challenge the traditional means of establishing epistemic authority. And ignorance and cynicism, bolstered by reactionary political rhetoric, has assumed renewed force in stripping academic institutions of their privileged positions in civil society.

Universities have, in this emergent social configuration, aptly described as postnormal times, struggled to sufficiently inform civil discourse or to speak to the populous by breaking out of its hypercompetitive milieu of academic credentialism. Intellectualism wears the badge of an out of touch liberal elitism, ostracised and marginalised by many elements of the new authoritarianism as well as online influencers reaching new audiences with pseudo-academic content. The university itself, particularly but not exclusively in the West, has been subsumed by a consumerist culture that knows the price of everything but the value of nothing. So, the time is now ripe for the exploration of a new model of higher education. For the university to give way to new institutions of higher learning. 

But, first, it is worth lingering on how the university has arrived at this ill-gotten mess.

Responses to the loss of academic authority in critical circles have centred, in its most radical and deconstructive guise, on the theory of university abolitionism. In the United States, this school of thought has been advanced in recent years by a panoply of African American theorists. In this American lineage, the potency of abolishing institutions in order to, as it were, ‘begin again’, draws on the intellectual debates (if not the practice) held in the US reconstruction, post-civil war period. Back then, there was hope that abolishing slavery could trigger a radical re-founding of society on another footing. That is, on the basis of truly emancipatory values extended to all quarters of society and to every institution, building a culture of egalitarianism and anti-racism. Black intellectuals and civil rights leaders such as W.E.B. du Bois took this possibility very seriously. In an iconic intellectual manifesto, The Undercommons, the theorists Fred Morten and Stephano Harney expand on this theme:

What is, so to speak, the object of abolition? Not so much the abolition of prisons but the abolition of a society that could have prisons, that could have slavery, that could have the wage, and therefore not abolition as the elimination of anything but abolition as the founding of a new society.

How would any society, distinguished by a complete absence of universities, appear to us? Or, more precisely, what type of new society in the contemporary era obviates the need for, or the urge to assert ownership over, universities and academic respectability? The barely conceivable thought of abolishing the university becomes partially explicable if we dwell on the observation, commonplace amongst many academic faculty in the West, that the university has become so thoroughly coopted by the prevailing economic rationality of the free market, it is no longer capable of defending or reinvigorating the well-intentioned traditions it was built upon. Hence, Peter Fleming muses in Dark Academia, in a similar vein to Richard Hall, that ‘the principles of neoliberalism are now so entrenched that one has to wonder whether the modern university is capable of, nay, worth being saved’. Perhaps not!

Scepticism that universities can reclaim their currency at a time of accelerating academic capitalism furnishes us with some pabulum. Universities were once famed, and indeed framed, as bastions of enlightenment and liberal thinking. These sensibilities trace themselves back to the well exhumed models of the university, inspired by Wilhelm von Humbolt (universities as centres of scholarship and collegiate self-governance), John Newman (universities fundamentally act to build character and professional competence) and Napoleon (universities furnish knowledge for the benefit of the nation). The intention behind these theories of the university’s purpose was to institutionalise ‘a new order of knowledge’. However, it is highly debatable whether these models still carry any weight in our world. We are at present in an impasse between epochs, where traditional elites and the liberal establishment are giving way. Hence, it is worth reflecting on whether universities are remnants of an old world defined by elevated academic prestige that is, with great alacrity, passing into oblivion. If we are to entertain this thought, we also need to wonder whether universities, alongside other organs of civil society such as the mainstream media, are fast becoming ‘legacy institutions’ in an epoch where knowledge is more accessible than at any point in human history. This trend is itself being given extra velocity, with the rise of generative AI increasingly obscuring the validity of authorial provenance. It has affected practices and procedures for essay writing and course work. It will most certainly have enormous ramifications for research, much of which is already repetitive, unoriginal and neo-scholastic in style and content, designed solely to produce articles that get into major journals.

If we are losing faith in the promise of higher education, it seems hardly surprising when the link between greater levels of social, occupational and income mobility, and higher education participation has become gravely attenuated, in at least the West. Universities have become debased over many years by the instrumental rationale for producing graduates for labour and business markets. This is the classical ‘functionalist’ approach to defending the extrinsic value of higher education, which has reduced it to mere cogs in the engine of the national economy. Functionalism dictates that all sectors of society are interlinked and serve each other’s interests, framed through the prevailing, binding discourse of macroeconomics. And yet even this motivation — of the graduate premium and better health outcomes — for pursuing higher education is becoming less compelling, holding less sway for those who are left behind. Indeed, underserved communities who have emotionally invested in the power of universities to significantly improve their generational life chances have reason to doubt their transformational potential. And this, after decades in which the intrinsic value of academia has been discredited by marketisation, state encroachment on academic autonomy, and the introduction of regimes of value in research and teaching. Is it unclear how the university can continue to justify itself, in at least its current institutional form, in these tragically self-defeating circumstances.

So, enter the Academy, the quixotic notion of return.

The Academy

Apart from the three European models, there is arguably another point of university genesis from which these evolutionary pathways diverged. Many western historians point to Bologna, founded in 1088, as the first fully institutionalised university. But the university is, as George Makdisi demonstrates so convincingly in The Rise of Colleges: Institutions of Learning in Islam and the West, is essentially a Muslim invention. The al-Azhar University in Cairo was established in 970, during the Fatimid period. Muslim feminists point to al-Qarawiyyin in Fez, build by Fatima al-Fihiri in 859, as the first true higher education institution. Other Muslim scholars point to Ez-Zitouna University in Tunis, founded around 737, as the first. All true and established historic facts. But within the annals of Western thought and philosophy, it is Plato’s Academy where it all begins. Let us also add the caveat that the Academy has become a sort of ‘prototype’ for the variety of educational establishments that would later emerge.

In the traditional telling, the Academy was a centre for philosophical inquiry, where a community of friends, companions and disciples convened to institutionalise intellectual discussion. Spatially, it occupied an area outside and to the northwest of the Athenian city walls. This location was loaded with significance. The peace and sanctity of the Academy, demarcated as sacred environs, was sustained by its distance from the bustle and chatter of the Athenian Agora (or marketplace) and the courts of law. As a sort of cloistered autonomous zone, we can read it as being free from state control and market interference. While the university has become the predominant organisational form of the Academy — a highly developed infrastructure and site of knowledge production — the terms are not strictly synonymous, although it would be unimaginable for us to think one without the other in the present day. Nonetheless, its image exercises a profound and enduring influence, at least as an imaginary amongst Western academics, eager to link modern academia to the philosophical ambience of its purported beginnings.

From its purified beginnings as a sort of saturnine space of the philosophers, a fellowship browsing the meadows of thought together, it would be easy to narrate a story of gradual corruption and decay. This would be to romanticise an idealised image of what we have purportedly lost. But the truth is, the space that the nominal academy of legend occupied was at a distance from the lay person, the hoi polloi, who were always considered as a source of trouble. It was never an institution meant for the demos (the people). Indeed, it was constituted in essence against ordinary folk.

Even with the unfolding of history, the academy was never prepared in any way for massification, democratisation, or what eventually transpired in the anglophone world, marketisation. The agora is the city. And after the eventual erosion of the post-war social consensus, the contemporary agora is now very much entrenched within the sacred space of the academy. The latter is firmly within the bounds of the city, a hostage to the marketplace. The chattering of those outside has become louder, closer, and more insistent. And yet the Academy has no answer for them. The university was/is not about to go back to ‘the Academy’ – however it is romantically conceived.

Instead, it moved forward to ‘Academic Capitalism’.

Academic Capitalism

The term was coined in 1990s by the American scholars of higher education, Sheila Slaughter and Gary Rhoades, in their analysis of the socio-economic trends and political realignments restructuring US higher education. Thereafter, they broadened out the scope of their investigation, pre-empting what would become the predominant mode of higher education in the West, at least in the anglophone world. Academic Capitalism, they argued, was a form of ‘capitalistic hybridisation’.

Evaluating their thesis, developed almost thirty years ago, it is striking how extensively the US modality of Academic Capitalism has been exported via what has become known as ‘transnational education’. Satellite and branch campuses of US and UK universities have emerged in many Middle Eastern and Asian countries, with degrees primarily focused on disciplines conducive to producing readily commercial and entrepreneurial outputs and applications. As a corollary of globalisation, this US model continues to extend itself through international higher education and the skills agenda of many countries across the world despite wide ranging reaction against it from anticolonial and nationalist quarters.

What Slaughter and Rhoades identified were inversions in logic that were instrumental in the rationalisation, and subsequently the growth and the embedding of Academic Capitalism in the context of US higher education. This occurred at a time when the US’s hegemonic global positioning was under threat and its competitiveness challenged in the 1970s. The oil shocks of the decade, resulting from the volatile situation in the Middle East (an echo of the current moment), added to the stagflation and increasing consumer prices in the US economy. In a crisis-position, on the domestic agenda the US government’s reaction become centred on, amongst other measures, increasing productivity and wealth creation through extension of market values into higher education in the 1980s. Universities were therefore hapless victims of the laws of globalisation: subjected to an abstract process denying all collective agency standing against it, and which demanded greater economic competitiveness from nation states in exchange for retaining and possibly enhancing their standing on the world stage (the world order out of which this was constructed invokes what the American sociologist, economic historian and originator of world-systems theory, Immanuel Wallerstein, would call coloniality).

Public universities, geared towards public service, refashioned themselves to fit the economic paradigm that was rapidly gaining ground, and what was to become known in the international arena as the Washington Consensus. Previously, public ends were secured by their separation from the domain of private interest; now, the logic of public service came to be redefined in the terms of the Washington Consensus. This was insidiously altered to become: public ends are only best served through furthering private interests. As Rhoades and Slaughter show, the former became subservient to the latter.

This logical inversion was accompanied by a change in the mix of university revenue streams, an increase in managerial control, and the commercialisation of intellectual labour. A reduction of block grants from federal government and individual states were compensated for by increases in tuition fees, funded by the student loan system, and private research grants. These changes bore the hallmarks of supply-side economics, that is the removal of regulations, public funding, and safeguards to increase the rates of private investment. The impact of this was to convert public universities into subsidised enterprises conducive to accommodating monopoly capital. Or, to phrase it differently, as accumulative infrastructures that amass private investment, for the purported benefit of the state and the very real benefit of individuals (for philanthropists, entrepreneurs, etc.). Hence, the influence of public universities as potentially redistributive institutions — an important basis of legitimacy for wider society and the state — was curbed with the indelible inscription of the ‘markers and proclivities of supply-side economics.’

This is the deeply ingrained logic of economic rationality or ‘supply-side higher education’ that would secure a foothold in UK and European higher education in the noughties. A necessary byproduct of this would be the discourse of ‘executive administration’ pervading justifications for all decision making. This new ‘professional ideology’ would acculturate, discipline, and direct the academic workforce; hypercompetition would be justified through the instrumentalised language of permanent scarcity, fiscal constraint, and the commercialisation of knowledge. All this has become all too commonplace. For instance, surveying the current UK higher education landscape, most universities now admit to having voluntary redundancy schemes in place, the financial dire straits of the sector combining with a seemingly irresistible business imperative. We have also seen the first merger, between the Universities of Kent and Greenwich, amongst institutions that intend to share a single executive team in a bid to keep down operational cost through streamlining services.

Public universities are increasingly forced to locate their legitimacy within the circumscribed discourse of supply side economics, which makes appeals to the public good and the intrinsic societal benefit of research and knowledge almost impossible to make with any authority whatsoever. The intellectual historian and observer of UK higher education, Stephan Collini, has stated that the benefits of free inquiry in research naturally generates economic by-products without the need to explicitly lean on this rationale. Disciplines with, at least initially, little seeming commercial value and evidently the result of untrammelled research, such as the theoretical physics in the 1920s, have inadvertently ended up contributing enormously to economic growth and development. Likewise, the fields of fine and public arts, and the wider cultural industries, have always punched above their weight in terms of contributing their proportion to GDP. And yet chiefly, if not solely, restricting research to immediately marketable disciplines through frameworks that metricise impact — creating regimes and hierarchies of value — ultimately narrows the scope of experimentation and inquiry. What then invariably follows is the limits placed on the potential for innovation; the exact opposite of what was intended. Appeals to economic rationality have invariably had the effect of sidelining the humanities and broad swathes of the social sciences. This has all grown out of an agenda that only values knowledge that can be seamlessly commercialised; one of the founding pillars of Academic Capitalism.

In the UK context, frameworks of research excellence have evolved since the 1980s to determine the real-world impact of research, purportedly holding academics accountable to wider society and policymakers. This has been accompanied by the greater integration of industry into higher education, as curriculum developers and legitimators of research and knowledge production. This tendency of ‘industry tailoring public universities programmes’ would become even more pronounced in the United States. It has become part of a management strategy to reduce intellectual labour to outputs of products and processes. In other words, the subjugation of intellectual vocations to wealth creation.

We can discern a vicious circle at play here. The new regimes of values within the academy creates a negative feedback loop between the conditions of the academic workforce and the regulatory systems designed to ensure accountability and quality assurance. Greater discontent and protests by academic staff can always be met with calls for greater managerial oversight and regulatory tightening. The system is set up to justify itself in all instances.

Considered overall, Academic Capitalism is a totalising, reductive ideology with little respect for pluralism. Hence, there is high degree of complicity that unites students, academic staff, and management in this joint venture. Students are increasingly seen as not just consumers but are judged on their ability to create wealth themselves; an assessment of how they capitalise on the investment of higher education participation, the notion known as ‘human capital theory’ amongst economists. The proceeds of academic research are seen in the same manner; that is the outcome of an investment in credentials. However, this is consequent on beating all other colleagues to the top, through the endless task of proving yourself against hopeless peers. The selfhood of faculty becomes completely submerged, defined and transfixed by the possibility of ‘success’. This race to secure academic supremacy has only reinforced the desperate conditions; the casualisation of the academic workforce and the proliferation of its browbeaten underclass. The methodological individualism of both student and academic is brought together and sustained under the relentless and merciless logic of Academic Capitalism. The modernisation of the university (cipher for being beholden to the dictates of globalisation), alongside public services, has been a principal factor impelling its evolution along this devastating path.

This has led Peter Fleming to characterise the university as the ‘Edu-factory’, emphasising that higher education has become a new capitalistic industry in its own right. It has become a conveyor belt, with academic staff and students reduced to inputs, and the outputs measured in research efficacy and salary increases. The ‘impersonal and unforgiving’ managerial hierarchies that have sprouted in university settings, and have demanded subservience to its priorities, have foreclosed all possible political routes to institutional reform.

What has become obvious is that the three European traditions underpinning the purpose of the university have been completely outmoded by Academic Capitalism. Higher education institutions, through new hierarchies of management, have long since effaced collegiate self-governance. Universities are no longer concerned with instilling ethos and character but bending to consumer and market demands. And any appeals to furthering the interests, economic or otherwise, of the state rings very hollow when a university education cannot guarantee a better standard of living or indeed a significant stake in society.

This acute crisis of meaning has resulted in what Fleming calls the ‘Zombie university’. No longer living, but not completely dead, occupying a liminal realm on the edge of infrastructural collapse. The image of the zombie institution is apt for other reasons, but also deeply troubling. The zombie is symbolic in the horror genre for mindless consumerism that dulls critical thinking. Universities are supposed to be the very opposite of this. And yet, one wonders. The purpose of the university is to feed on lifeless profit. The liberal arguments for higher education have short-circuited themselves, leaving the university vulnerable to becoming an incarnation of the living dead stalking the earth.

Yet, there are attempts within the ‘Academy’ to keep the Zombie moving. Enter ‘Academic citizenship’.

Academic citizenship

Even during the rise and the supremacy of Academic Capitalism, universities have had to establish means to increase access for working class and marginalised communities. Higher education institutions had to find ways to accommodate them through various programmes of Equity, Diversity and Inclusion (EDI). The impetuous for these measures was strengthened in the aftermath of the 2020 killing of George Floyd in the US and the subsequent mobilisations of Black Lives Matter. Moreover, the ‘Rhodes Must Fall’ student campaign in South Africa, unleashed a tidal wave of fervour for decolonising the Academy, the ripple effects felt across other parts of the world. The regulatory background has also provided an added accelerant. In return for UK universities charging the maximum amount of tuition fees for undergraduate degrees, institutions have been obliged to establish schemes to widen participation and maintain the quality of the student experience. Arrangements around access have matured over a longer period since the late 1990s in the British context; while the events propelling anti-racism work has ebbed and flowed, occurring in sudden spasms and jolts to shock the system. In the US, the counter insurgency against EDI is well underway. President Trump has overseen a rolling back of EDI initiatives: a notable win in the culture wars that has seen progress in the enactment of the neoconservative side of his agenda.

In many respects, the regulatory mechanisms, absorbing some of the utopian energies of the anti-racist and anticolonial movements, fits in seamlessly with the logic of students as consumers. The customer experience in the retail sector has been projected through higher education institutions. Hence, the salience attached to the student experience on campus, with regulators becoming something akin to consumer watchdogs that punish unfair trading practices and falsely advertised products. Widening the student base of higher education is also to extend the market for the sector, as well as to inevitably manage the demographic shift that has occurred with the popularisation of the university system. On the EDI front, many critical educators have been quick to label university measures ‘performative’ and simply part of a branding and marketing exercise that categorically refuses to confront the substance of institutional racism.

Notwithstanding this dynamic, the new regulatory regime has also given academic faculty and higher education practitioners a means to further their own more radical agendas, through tapping into legitimate initiatives to transform the university. Within the confines of Academic Capitalism, one also finds models of inclusive education advanced with varying levels of (dis)continuity with the status quo. Many of these models clash with one another, reflecting the reality that the university remains a site of contestation despite continuing attempts at depoliticisation and the homogenising discourses of neoliberalism.

On the one end of the spectrum, a cross-section of practitioners promote transformative modes of education, that, put simply, promote democratic pedagogy and problematise the disjunction between teacher and student. This is to challenge academic hierarchies, Eurocentric means of knowledge production, and social stratifications of prestige. It entails wholescale structural reform and institutional renewal. And on the other end, strictly meritocratic approaches seek to narrow the field of inclusion to access, identifying, and championing talented students from non-traditional backgrounds with few opportunities. The latter discourse and practice emphasise academic excellence and talent, bolstering what the widening participation researcher Penny Jane Burke identifies as the ‘deficit framing’ which creates binaries within the student body, between the deserving and underserving poor. The outcome is to maintain the hierarchies of knowledge and status that delegitimises the academy in the minds of those that feel left behind.

Approaches to inclusive education leverage existing schemes and frameworks that attempt to at least smooth over the sharp edges of higher education preserved by persistent cycles of structural inequality. The endless task of mitigating the worst excesses of Academic Capitalism, structurally located within the modern institution, has been assumed by faculty staff themselves acting as ‘academic citizens’. In relation to the academic workforce, this surplus citizenship labour has been instrumental in staving off the institutional collapse foretold by Peter Fleming.

Academic citizenship goes far beyond the conventional spheres of teaching and research. We can consider it to be service centred work. Typically, it surfaces in peer or student mentoring, academic development, involvement in EDI and WP (widening participation) initiatives, community and public engagement and so on. It is the type of activity that at its root sustains the functioning of institutions, socially reproducing the university as a community of peers: a type of ‘domestic’ institutional labour that often goes unnoticed by senior management. And yet it is crucial to engendering a culture which has the virtuous citizen at its heart. That is, it refuses the tendency of Academic Capitalism to reduce intellectual labour to mere utility.

The education researcher, social philosopher, and Professor at University of Bristol, Bruce MacFarlane, is one of the pioneers behind the concept of academic citizenship. He has carefully documented how the pressures and strains induced by marketisation has constrained the time and space for citizenship activity. Now the literature on academic citizenship has been bludgeoning. It appears that faculty staff have found ways to continue to enact citizenship behaviour not despite but because of toxic university cultures.

It is true that academic citizenship can adopt an individualistic tenor, as well as assuming communitarian forms. The former captures the need for marginalised and precarious early years academics to show their worth beyond their core activities. It is almost a non-negotiable survival instinct, translatable into promotional criteria and models of performance management. And it is consistent with the dictates of modern higher education and its professional ideologies. But the communitarian mode of citizenship, modelling ‘solidaristic’ forms of consciousness, suggests that a capacity for community building, a certain workforce ethics, remains even in a sector depleted of job security, appreciation, and recognition.

The negation and ‘invisibilisation’ of ‘minoritised’ faculty staff – in the words of the professor of race and equality Heidi Mirza – with their felt distance from decision-making roles, has become ubiquitous in the sector. Central to this is how power is exercised through the abstract forces of supply side higher education, disempowering the ability of faculty to realise collective agency themselves (notwithstanding the influence of trade union organising) and turning them against each other. However, many faculty have, within the emerging research on academic citizenship, expressed how citizenship behaviour is something that comes naturally regardless of the academic labour conditions. There is an intrinsic motivation for it that does not have formal acknowledgment or recognition as its aim. It is a strain of institutional ethics and academic duty that counters the abstraction of market forces. One that has power sharing from below as its core. As such, it could be considered as radical and transformative as the act of complaining to expose institutional pathologies, as has been detailed by the feminist, independent researcher, Sarah Ahmed.

Citizenship activity is very much grounded in what it means to live a virtuous institutional life. It is, to cite the sociologist Les Back, to live an examinant life, reflecting on the ethics of one’s own actions and choices. It is ultimately an attempt to re-found the university on a micro-political level at a time where Academic Capitalism drains away any sense of collective ethics from the Academy. This dimension of academic citizenship mirrors what some education practitioners posit as the capabilities approach to widening participation. The latter stresses that increasing access to higher education is ultimately about giving students from non-traditional backgrounds the capability to live a good life. It is to extend the capacity to make rational, moral choices on how to shape a fulfilling, flourishing life, beyond any reduction to utilitarian ends. A refusal of institutional recognition by at least some involved in citizenship labour can be considered a possible prefiguration of a distributed, diffuse Academy without the operative institutional machinery of the university. It is a challenge to the predominant university culture from within; both supporting and undermining its liberal credentials, a return to intellectual labour as an ontological vocation (the formulation of the radical Latin American educator, Paulo Feire) that retains strong ties to forms of relationality, against the individualism consuming the university. Crucially, it is a rejection of the professional ideologies that made academia a misery for so many.

Can academic citizenship save the university?

In seriously engaging with the question of university abolitionism, we are led to the thought of how the phenomenon of a de-institutionalised Academy may appear to us. Here, we should ponder on the potential for reactivating the community of peers at the heart of the Academy. This could perhaps be a community of academic citizens that have cast off the university as the Academy’s mental asylum, prison, and ivory tower, all rolled into one. It means a dissolution of the boundaries that have separated the demos and academy; to inaugurate a genuinely mass higher education system that exists in and amongst local communities. It is to change direction: the route taken to reimagine an alternative to the academic as the heir to Plato’s Academy, and all the missteps, symbolic or actual, that has informed the European image of intellectual life.

The Academy itself can perhaps be saved, but the university cannot in its existing institutional form, as it lurches from financial catastrophe to existential crisis. But to save the Academy we need to begin again by revitalising its first principles, and only by rediscovering it from an alternative genesis. In other words, not enveloped by elitism, meritocracy, and credentialism, but elevated in its distance from suffocating and restrictive ideologies. One that brings the academic community back into contact with a renewed moral rationality, prior and beyond the economic rationality of supply side higher education. That is, for the Academy to answer the chatter and mutterings questioning its relevance and purpose, it must address the critical issues of its engagement with a collective, democratic ethics. This needs to galvanise civic society and the public realm in an epoch where the traditional authority of higher education is seemingly incapable of preserving the institutional form of the university.

References

The following works are cited directly or built upon in this essay: Sara Ahmed, No is Not a Lonely Utterance: The Art and Activism of Complaining (Allen Lane, 2005); Penny Jane Burke, The Right to Higher Education: Beyond Widening Participation (Routledge, 2012); M Chenge, ‘Re-examining and developing the notion of academic citizenship: A critical literature review, Higher Education Quarterly, 2023; Stephan Collini, Speaking of Universities (Verso, 2017); J Cook and L Nyhagen, Intersectional Feminist Research Methodologies: Applications in the Social Sciences and the Humanities (Routledge, 2024); Les Back, Academic Diary, (Goldsmiths University Press, 2016); Richard Hall, The Hopeless University, Intellectual Work at the end of The End of History (Mayfly, 2012); Peter Fleming, Dark Academia (Pluto Press, 2021); Y Sheeran, B Brown, and S Baker, ‘Conflicting philosophies of inclusion: the contestation of knowledge in widening participation’, London Review of Education 5(3):249. 2007; Paulo Freire, Pedagogy of the Oppressed (Penguin, Modern Classics, 2017); Bruce MacFarlane, ‘The Disengaged Academic: The Retreat from Citizenship’, Higher Education Quarterly (2005); Ziauddin Sardar and Henzell-Thomas, J. (2018), Rethinking Reform in Higher Education: From Islamization to Integration of Knowledge (The International Institute of Islamic Thought, 2018); Sheila Slaughter and Gary Rhoades, ‘Academic Capitalism, Managed Professionals, and Supply-Side Higher Education’ Social Text 51(51):9 1997; M Walker, ‘Widening participation; widening capability’, London Review of Education, Vol. 6, No. 3, 267–279, 2008.